Well, I think we have made a connection. I just found the information about the marriage. Robert F. McNay, b. 1843 in KY, age 22, and a farmer married Lucretia I. Routt, b. 1845 in KY, on 21 Mar. 1865. Father: Columbus Routt born in VA, Mother ? (you just provided) born in KY. Married by Rev. Marcus Arnold (This Arnold is in my Arnold family in Pendleton Co.) I don't know if you would be interested in the McNay line in which Belle married. You might want the names of her children though. I believe we can be pretty sure she died around 1879. I have the Barton papers around here somewhere that mentioned the two brothers in the civil war. I believe it said they were killed. As soon as I find it, I will let you know. Isabella was in Campbell Co. in 1870, which is a stone's throw from Covington. Thank you so much for reponding to my posting. I have information from another Routt researcher who had a Columbus in his line, but the father was Peter Routt. Don't know if they are connected or not.