I'm married to a Reedy but have been working on the line with my husband and his cousins. There are several lines, we believe , up here in Ohio that came from Rockingham, Grayson and Shenandoah Co, Virginia after the Civil War , 1870's. My husband's , from Tom's Brook, VA, left after the 1870 census and arrived by 1875, Champaign County, Ohio. John Reedy and Susanah Swartz. Were in Maryland the few years. Have you tried reading the online Shenandoah County, VA marriage records? There is also a genealogy get -together there once a year and the Reedys come back from across the US for this. We have attended twice and found it very helpful.