John Paul = 2 Jul 1835 Wayne co OH Anne Mallory
I believe Anne was from Eaton's Corners Quebec Canada and came to Ohio with her siblings, including a sister Amelia and Eliza, and brothers Conroy and Caleb.
Ann Mallory = 2 Jul 1835 Wayne co OH John Paul
Not sure if they are the same couple living in Defiance co in 1860.
Anne's brother Conroy moved to Williams Co while brother Caleb P Mallory moved back to Canada where he was preacher at the Huntington Universalist church for 38 years.
Sister eliza married thomas L Summerton
Another sister married a SP Stevens and moved to chattanooga
Still another, Amelia, married Nathan Landis
Caleb P Mallory married1835 Wayne Co Mary Ann Parsons and later married sisters in Canada
Conroy Ward Mallory married Mary Jane Burdett in Wayne Co in 1848 and subsequent to her death, married Amanda Cummingham in Williams co.
1850 census Williams Co OH
John Paul 1805= Ann Paul 1812 1850 census William Co OH
John Paul 1838
Eliza Paul 1836
Frances A Paul 1844
1860 census Defiance Co OH
John Paul 1807= Ann1814
John Paul 1848
Jennie Paul 1846