States: New York: Otsego
WOW! That's the fastest service I have ever received - you posted your response only minutes after I posted my query.
It looks like you found the correct Ida Scofield because my earlier info said she was born in 1870, and that fits with the age 9 given in the 1880 census, assuming her birthday was after June. I think I'll order the census film and give that name NIRARD SCOFIELD another look. It could be Hiram. I've never seen Nirard as a given name before.
Thanks much for your help.