Hi, Virgil... thanks for the reply. I have a page of the 1880 Census for Cutler and it shows John and Susan living there, with a 7 y.o. boarder named Eliza, but have no relation there yet. Unfortunately, my Grandmother isn't listed, even though she was born 24 Apr 1880, which is a mystery. Also shown just above and below this record on the 1880 Census is a listing for John's parents: James, Mary and his sister, Mary (age 28), and a listing for John's brother, Henry Reed Huntley and his wife, Julia Ann and their children. Do you have a copy of the 1880 Cutler Census? If not, I can try to send it to you. Also, can you share how you are related to Annie Elizabeth, what lines? That would be great, since we have no other living relatives on that side, that we know of. Thanks much. Sheila W.