Re: Virginia MAryland Connections ?
-
In reply to:
Re: Virginia MAryland Connections ?
Judie Schatz 3/13/08
I would have to agree with Judie.According to the first
twelve markers, there is little evidence for a connection
between the Benoni Fanning line F-19 and Bryan Fannin(g) of Amelia Co., Va. F-2 and others.
F-19 (Benoni) is mismatched on 6 markers out of 12 comparing to F-2 (Bryan Fanning of Amelia Co., Va) and 7 markers out of 12 comparing to F-5 and F-13 (Chestnut Creek John Fanning).
The confusion may be due to using F-15 as the standard for Bryan Fanning and comparing it to F-19. F-15 has been proven to be a non-parental event.
F-1 thru F-5, F-7 thru 10 and F-12 & F-18 are the establishing lines for Bryan Fanning of Amelia Co., Va. b. 1698 and Chestnut Creek John Fanning, not F-15
F-15 and F-19 seem to be a new line of Fannins or Fannings and even they are not matched on three markers out of 12.
Not to mention the different Haplogroup.
Sincerely,
Pat Fannin