Giles of Henrico DNA
-
In reply to:
Quick Summary of Carter DNA
Richard Zieman 6/17/11
Giles Carter of Henrico County VA ......................... Rebecca R. Dyer, NSDAR, NSCDXVIIC
June 2011: The Jury is still out; we must respect - but not accept without question - the excellent work
of Peyton Franklin Carter III, here and over the years on the Carter GenForum.Begin with the ONE known kit:
Carter Cousins Kit 23874: Haplogroup I1a - No Matches, No approximations -
13 23 14 10 13 14 10 16 12 12 11 28 -/- 15898 11 23 16 20 29 12 14 15 16
1. Giles of Henrico
2. Theodrick Carter I married Elizabeth
3. Theodrick Carter II married Anne Waddill
4. John Carter born 1737
5. James Carter married Amy Motley
6. Joseph Motley Carter married Mary Jane Doran
7. John Coffee Carter married Arabella Evans
8. John McCoy Carter married Margaret Ann Morgan
Has potential weak spots, but is somewhat credible.
Separately, it is s clear contradiction between Peyton in Haplo R1b1a2: His tens in markers 4 and 9 are quite unique -
SEEMS to connect to the few postings for Isle of Wight.However, we already know those genealogies
are quite suspect, from the "Presidents" book.
Peyton Franklin Carter III - Kit No. 205272- 24 of 25 match to the Isle of Wight
13 24 14 10 11 14 12 12 10 13 13 29 -/-17 9-10 11 11 24 15 20 28 15-15-17-18
His prior genealogy is impeccable back to John Carter 1775 of Amelia Co VA:
1. Giles Carter
2. Theodrick Carter
3. Theodrick Carter II
4. Waddill Carter (1745-1782) m. Mildred Wade
5. John Carter (1775-1852) m. Mary Carter (of the Barford)
6. William R. Carter (1809-1886) m. Mary Eliz. Pollard
7. Peyton F. Carter (1858 - 1930) m. Mary Eliz. Angle
8. Benjamin Franklin Carter (1891-1977) m. Frances Gretchen Upshur
9. Peyton II
1850 US Census VA Amelia
HH 265 Wm. R. Carter 40 Carpenter Mary 22 Otelia 3 Richard Bingham 12(no Peyton *)
HH 267 John Carter 76 None (no occupation) Onney 60
1860 US Census VA Amelia Dist 1 HH 68
W. R. Carter 49 Mary E. 29 Otelia 13 Margaret 9 Joanna 8 Lelia 7 Nancy E. 6 Peyton F. 2 * and unnamed daughter 3 months (Mary Ann)
Separately, let's remember that Peyton has proven the father of Giles as Theodore - contrary to The Books listing Giles and Elizabeth Tracey WHO HAD NO CHILDREN:
Name: Giles Carter Birth: 1634 in Cirenchester (Glochestershire), England
Christening: 24 APR 1635 Cirencester Death: 12 FEB 1700/01 in Turkey Island,Henrico, VA
"Note: The relationship between Giles Carter and Elizabeth Tracey produced no children. Plaque in Cold Aston church tells the story and documents that they died with out producing an heir. Other research in England states likewise. It is important to realize that Giles MAY be of this family but he is not a son of Giles and Elizabeth Tracey Carter. Giles 1634 came to America, married Hannah (Crewes?) "
More Replies:
-
Re: Giles of Henrico DNA
Holly Hampton 11/16/11
-
Re: Giles of Henrico DNA
Peyton Carter 5/07/13
-
Balancing Claims and Documentation
Holly Hampton 5/08/13
-
Balancing Claims and Documentation
-
Re: Giles of Henrico DNA